This week, Campus Reform reported that The University of Massachusetts-Lowell has recently
terminated its dean of the Solomont School of Nursing, Leslie Neal-Boylan, reportedly in response to a letter she sent out to students and the school community.
Did Neal-Boylan make an insensitive comment about George Floyd? Advocate for renaming a library after David Duke? No. Here are the shocking, offending words:
"I am writing to express my concern and condemnation of the recent (and past) acts of violence against people of color. Recent events recall a tragic history of racism and bias that continue to thrive in this country. I despair for our future as a nation if we do not stand up against violence against anyone. BLACK LIVES MATTER, but also, EVERYONE'S LIFE MATTERS...No one should have to live in fear that they will be targeted for how they look or what they believe."
Terrible, right?
...wait.
Yes, most level-headed people will find nothing fireable in that excerpt -- and, at the same time, sadly recognize what part somebody
else considered to be fireable. After someone contacted the university, via social media (of course), that Neal-Boylan included the phrase "EVERYONE'S LIFE MATTERS," Neal-Boylan was gone within days. The only encouraging part of this story is that she is vigorously advocating for herself, and, on social media (of course), many others are advocating for them, as well. Two candidates who were considering joining that faculty -- due to their admiration of Neal-Boylan -- are now apparently reconsidering.
In an unrelated/related story, Grant Napear
is out as the play-by-play announcer after a tweet. Former King DeMarcus Cousins asked Napear for his take on Black Lives Matter. Napear's response:
"Hey!!!! How are you? Thought you forgot about me. Haven't heard from you in years. ALL LIVES MATTER...EVERY SINGLE ONE!!!"
Welp! That's it. He's gone. Napear apologized on his way out the door for his, uh, hateful words, saying that he didn't realize that the phrase "All Lives Matter" is "counter to what BLM was trying to get across."
If anyone thinks that saying that "all lives matter" is somehow hostile to any one group, then obviously there's some sort of failure to communicate.
As I blogged in January 2017, in
"Of Lives and Mattering,"
I do understand that most who say "black lives matter" do believe that other lives matter, as well, but they also believe that African-Americans are being disproportionately targeted by police. One may agree with that assertion. One may disagree. But at least the conversation can begin from there.
But if "BLM" deserves the benefit of the doubt, then the same is true for "ALM." If people should not mentally add "only" to someone else's "Black Lives Matter," then others should not mentally add "Except Black Lives" to someone else's "All Lives Matter."
Then there are the shoddy Internet comparisons. One argues that saying "all lives matter" is like a fire department hosing down all the houses on the street, not just the one burning, because "all houses matter." Or a surgeon operating on every bone in your body, not just the one that is broken, because "all bones matter." But I look at the lives being lost on the news. Folks, it's not just one house on fire. I see many broken bones, and they're not all one color.
Do I understand why people choose to say something as specific as "Black Lives Matter"? Of course. The killings of Ahmaud Arbery, Breonna Taylor, and George Floyd are three worthy examples. I won't throw shade on someone who takes the time to focus on their needless, unjustified deaths. Conversely, though, people who choose to include other people's lives, rather than to focus only upon one race, are not white supremacists for doing so. Actual white supremacists -- actual ones, not just anyone who disagrees with a leftist -- probably wouldn't be caught
dead saying something as unifying and anodyne as "all lives matter."
Arbery, Taylor, and Floyd should be alive today. Forcing Leslie Neal-Boylan and Grant Napear out of their jobs will do N-O-T-H-I-N-G to advance anyone's cause. It will only alienate many people who want to be allies, because they used the "wrong three words" to express their support.
Say what you want to say. But no one should lose a job for saying that every single life has value.